MENUMENU
  • Who we are
        • Who we are

          We are innovative. We are impact-oriented. We are science-driven. We are Quantis.

          Discover Quantis

        • Discover Quantis
          • About Quantis
          • Why Quantis
          • Locations
        • Talent
          • Our people
          • Join us
  • What we do
        • What we do

          Helping our clients solve critical environmental challenges is our sole purpose. We’re your expert guide on the journey from business as usual to
          business at its best.

          Discover our approach

        • Sustainability transformation journey
          • Our approach
          • Our services
        • Our expertise
          • Biodiversity
          • Climate
          • Land + Agriculture
          • Plastics
          • Water
  • Who we guide
        • Who we guide

          We help our clients realize the best versions of their businesses — successful, sustainable and prepared for the future.

          Discover our clients

        • Our impact
          • Clients
          • Case Studies
          • Collaborative Initiatives
        • Our key sectors
          • Food + Beverage
          • Cosmetics + Personal Care
          • Fashion + Sporting Goods
          • Other sectors
  • What we think
        • What we think

          The latest from Quantis, including news, think pieces, reports, scientific publications and more on the latest developments in sustainability.

          Discover our insights

        • Resources
          • News + Insights
          • Reports + Publications
          • Events
          • Webinars
          • Research
          • Press Room
Quantis is a leading environmental sustainability consultancy that partners with major organizations across the globe to drive sustainable transformation and align business with planetary boundaries.
MENUMENU
  • Who we are
        • Who we are

          We are innovative. We are impact-oriented. We are science-driven. We are Quantis.

          Discover Quantis

        • Discover Quantis
          • About Quantis
          • Why Quantis
          • Locations
        • Talent
          • Our people
          • Join us
  • What we do
        • What we do

          Helping our clients solve critical environmental challenges is our sole purpose. We’re your expert guide on the journey from business as usual to
          business at its best.

          Discover our approach

        • Sustainability transformation journey
          • Our approach
          • Our services
        • Our expertise
          • Biodiversity
          • Climate
          • Land + Agriculture
          • Plastics
          • Water
  • Who we guide
        • Who we guide

          We help our clients realize the best versions of their businesses — successful, sustainable and prepared for the future.

          Discover our clients

        • Our impact
          • Clients
          • Case Studies
          • Collaborative Initiatives
        • Our key sectors
          • Food + Beverage
          • Cosmetics + Personal Care
          • Fashion + Sporting Goods
          • Other sectors
  • What we think
        • What we think

          The latest from Quantis, including news, think pieces, reports, scientific publications and more on the latest developments in sustainability.

          Discover our insights

        • Resources
          • News + Insights
          • Reports + Publications
          • Events
          • Webinars
          • Research
          • Press Room
  • Contact
  • Contact
Insights > As US Supreme Court reins in EPA’s climate authority, businesses must double down on action

As US Supreme Court reins in EPA’s climate authority, businesses must double down on action

08 | 07 | 2022
renewable energy

We encourage our clients to not lose heart and to continue to broaden, expand and accelerate their efforts to align with planetary boundaries

The US Supreme Court (SCOTUS) dealt a harsh blow to climate action on June 30, 2022 with its ruling on West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency (WV v. EPA), which limits the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) authority to regulate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and combat the planet’s unfolding environmental emergency. The decision may significantly curtail the Agency’s ability to reduce emissions from existing power plants and address environmental issues in other sectors, posing a major setback in tackling the global climate crisis.

On the heels of controversial rulings that limit access to reproductive health — an essential component of climate adaptation and resilience — and challenge progress on gun control, the 6-3 vote suggests that the Clean Air Act does not give the EPA the authority to impose wide-reaching GHG emissions regulations on the power sector. The move effectively reduces the tools the EPA has at its disposal to quickly and efficiently drive the grid towards decarbonization. Per the New York Times, “the decision stripped President Biden of a crucial tool in his efforts to control pollution.”

The ruling couldn’t come at a worse time. Scientists now generally accept that our best hope of limiting global warming to 1.5ºC and mitigating the worst case scenario of climate change is for humanity, and its institutions, to act decisively now. To achieve this, global GHG emissions must peak by 2025 and be reduced by 43% by 2030. For the United States to meet its national commitments under the Paris Climate Agreement, the Biden Administration has proposed to cut economy-wide emissions 50% by 2030, alongside a complete decarbonization of the power sector — one of the largest sources of GHG emissions in the US — by 2035. This will prove all the more challenging now that the Executive Branch’s ability to drive systemic change through regulation has been severely compromised.

The SCOTUS docket is discretionary and the decision to rule on WV v. EPA, which challenges a regulation that had never even taken effect, was an unusual one. There was no clear urgency to take up the case, making the ideological and political motive of the decision acutely clear. The Court’s conservative majority seems to be working their way down a list of agenda items on behalf of the American far right. What is perhaps the most troublesome aspect of this case, as Ian Millihiser of Vox points out, is that through the West Virginia decision the Supreme Court has “effectively placed itself at the head of much of the executive branch of the federal government.” This is particularly problematic for the environmental cause. As Justice Kagan persuasively argues in her dissenting opinion, the Court has effectively told the EPA’s climate experts that they are not authorized to do their job under the Clean Air Act. The judiciary is now, in effect, the ultimate arbiter in matters of climate policy.

That is, unless a gridlocked US Congress — which also notably lacks in environmental expertise — decides to pass the kind of sweeping climate legislation that has eluded it for decades. By punting the responsibility to Congress, SCOTUS has potentially mired environmental action to even more bureaucratic inaction. 

In terms of what this could mean for businesses, only time will tell. It’s at least true that this ruling doesn’t directly affect how companies are addressing their Scope 1 and 3 emissions but the unprecedented decision could beget more challenges to the EPA’s authority and governmental environmental action in general. In the long-run, the legal climate could make it increasingly difficult for businesses to meet their voluntarily set targets without regulation driving the economy toward decarbonization. 

Though it’s disheartening that US leaders are playing politics at the expense of the planet (and all those occupying it), we encourage our clients to not lose heart and continue to broaden, expand and accelerate their efforts to align with planetary boundaries. While governments can seem increasingly erratic in their handling of environmental matters, the business world continues to have an opportunity — and a duty — to drive positive change for the benefit of people and planet. We, at Quantis, have faith that businesses understand what’s in their own collective best interests. 

And it’s why we do what we do.

Share this article

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Author(s)
Cullen Mitchell Sustainability Consultant
John Willard Senior Sustainability Strategist

Latest resources

IPCC report 2022
06 | 04 | 22
Insights

The latest IPCC report calls for rapid transformations across all sectors.

Rapid transformations across all sectors and systems is the only way to avoid the worst impacts of the climate crisis.

SEC Climate disclosure - Everything you need to know about the SEC’s proposed climate disclosure rule
31 | 03 | 22
Our News

Everything you need to know about the SEC’s proposed climate disclosure rule

The rule would require public companies to provide investors with information on the climate risks they face.

More news and insights +

Top
TOP

Subscribe to the Quantis Quarterly

Register
Quantis Twitter Quantis Linkedin

7 offices
worldwide

Switzerland
(Lausanne, Bellinzona, Zürich)

France
Germany
Italy
USA

Quantis is a leading environmental sustainability consultancy that partners with major organizations across the globe to drive sustainable transformation and align business with planetary boundaries.
2023 Quantis ©
All rights reserved

Privacy Portal

  • Who we are
    • Discover Quantis
      • About Quantis
      • Why Quantis
      • Locations
    • Talent
      • Our people
      • Join us
  • What we do
    • Sustainability transformation journey
      • Our approach
      • Our services
    • Our expertise
      • Biodiversity
      • Climate
      • Land + Agriculture
      • Plastics
      • Water
  • Who we guide
    • Our impact
      • Clients
      • Case Studies
      • Collaborative Initiatives
    • Our key sectors
      • Food + Beverage
      • Cosmetics + Personal Care
      • Fashion + Sporting Goods
      • Other sectors
  • What we think
    • Resources
      • News + Insights
      • Reports + Publications
      • Events
      • Webinars
      • Research
      • Press Room
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. See our Privacy Portal for more details. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT